fantasy football preview 2008
Jason posted on August 25th, 2008
Sometimes I think that fantasy football is my least favorite fantasy sport. As someone with loads of free time and an unbridled urge to succeed in virtual reality where I could not succeed in actual reality, I like t
The third component of fantasy sports is much more prevalent in fantasy football than in baseball or basketball, and this is the very reason that I like football least. That component is luck. No matter how much research you do, how much you know about players and coaches and offensive schemes, it all comes down to one number: 16. There are only sixteen games in a fantasy football season (and many leagues hold their championship game in Week 16, as starters on playoff-bound teams are often rested in Week 17, thereby reducing their season to fifteen meaningful games). This is a very small sample size compared to 162 baseball games, 82 basketball games, and however many games they play in hockey (if that sport’s still around). On any given week, anything can happen: Tom Brady can go without a touchdown, the Bears could score 42 points against your defense, Stephen Jackson can leave a game after one play. Here’s a statistical study of six weeks in the life of an NFL running back to help illustrate the randomness of fantasy football (carries – yards rushing – touchdowns – fantasy points; I’m leaving out receptions to make it as uncomplicated as possible):
Week 1: 30 – 296 – 3 – 47.6
Week 2: 11 –45 – 0 – 4.5
Week 3: DNP
Week 4: DNP
Week 5: 15 – 116 – 2 – 23.6
Week 6: 14 – 3 – 0 – .3
That’s 47.6 points, then 4.5, then two DNPs, then 23.6, then .3 points per week for the guy who will most likely be the #2 overall pick in your league: Adrian Peterson. No one will disagree with you if you say the guy’s a beast, but his talent does not often result in consistent and positive fantasy points.
While Peterson is an extreme example, this is the case with all football players. Guys will have great games, guys will have stink-bombs, guys will play ok – and there’s nothing you can do but let them play out their full sixteen games. Compare this to baseball, where I can tell you that Kosuke Fukudome is a must play at home (where his OBP is .411 in 58 games versus .326 in 54 games on the road) and Ryan Howard could be benched against lefties (he’s batting .186 in 188 ABs against lefties compared to .271 in 266 ABs against righties this year, with career splits of .221 and .308) and you see what I’m getting at. For the uber nerd like myself, football is frustrating because of its small sample size and strong reliance on luck, and because quite often these factors result in losing to girls. Which sucks.
(Hear me now: I’m not saying luck isn’t involved in fantasy baseball or basketball. For example, talk to the people who took Carl Crawford in the first, thought they had a gems in Robby Cano and Travis Hafner on the right side of their infield, and just knew their three-headed monster of Bedard-Harang-Chris Young would K them right to their league title. It’s just that you’re able to overcome injuries or poor performance a lot more easily in baseball because there are 162 freaking games.)
Still, that does not mean that my research for football, for all its potential meaninglessness, is any less fervent or thorough. I approach football just as I approach baseball, and actually usually play in more football leagues per season (four this year) compared to baseball (one I care about more than my family, one I don’t really care about, and one in which I merely consult on the draft and trades, leaving the day-to-day operations to my partner). It is precisely because of the fact that it’s only sixteen games that fantasy football is the most popular sports – anybody can put together the team and everyone has a chance to win, which is not the case for other fantasy sports.
Alright, let’s start with the general tips, then get on with the rankings.
1) Do your research. This may seem obvious, but if you wing it, you’ll lose. Sure, anyone with a fundamental knowledge of football can navigate through the first few rounds, but what happens in Round 8 when you’re looking for a 3rd receiver and are deciding between Chris Chambers and Santana Moss?
(Actually, they’d be pretty solid third WRs.)
At the very least, visit the fantasy sections of ESPN, Yahoo, and CBS Sportsline to get a general idea of two things: what statistics players put up last year and where players are being drafting. Yeah, odds are good that Peyton Manning will have around 30 TDs and he’s a high pick, but what about a guy like Phillip Rivers? Where’s he being drafted in relation to Jay Cutler or David Garrad? Can you get those guys in the 12th round, whereas you’d need to draft Peyton in the 2nd?
Go into the draft with some stuff printed out with last year’s stats. That’ll give you a cheat sheet to look over during the draft. Additionally, I like to highlight certain guys I like, making notes on the side. Do whatever makes you comfortable, but you should have a little bit of paperwork to refer to during the draft and to keep you grounded.
2) Lie and manipulate. If you are in a league with friends, constantly engage them in conversations before the draft. Feel them out about their battle plans, who they like, etc and reciprocate with information that is entirely false. The important thing is to be sincere and seem honest. A good way to do this is by saying stuff like, “You know, I don’t even know if I should tell you this, but I think last year was not a fluke for Big Ben and see him getting even better” when you secretly think that there’s no chance in hell he throws for 22 TDs, let alone the 32 he threw for last year
Say you have the 5th pick in the first round, and your buddy has the 4th. You really, really want Joseph Addai, but think your buddy at 4 is going to take him. The solution: talk up another player. “Dude, I love Stephen Jackson. The Rams have drastically improved in the offseason and he’s motivated with that holdout. But c’mon - don’t take him, dude. I’m calling dibbs on him.” There’s a chance that your buddy at 4 will then take Jackson in the hopes of screwing you over, and you’ll get Addai. Remember, the other owners in your league are just as soulless as you are, just much, much dumber. The point is, NEVER show your true hand. Flaunt your fake hand constantly.
3) Know your scoring system and positions. Football leagues often times have different scoring rules and settings. Are QB TDs worth four points or six? Are there points awarded for receptions? If so, how many? Do you start two QBs every week or just one? (I personally think you’re not a man unless you’re in a two QB league; why should the most important position in the field be relegated to secondary status in leagues? Would you draft Earnest Graham before Drew Brees in real life?) Is there a WR/RB flex position? How many bench spots are there?
These are all important questions that can drastically influence the way you draft. Drew Brees is a late second round pick in a two-QB league. Reggie Bush has a lot more value in a PPR (points per reception) league; Michael Turner, he of 11 career receptions, does not.
4) Don’t panic, and start or stay off the waves. Countless mistakes are made during the draft because the manager was panicking. Don’t be that dude. When your pick is on its way back to you, be sure to have at least two choices ready. This way, if the guy ahead of you takes the player you wanted, you don’t make a rash decision and end up taking a kicker in the 5th round.
A good deal of draft panic derives from position runs. This happens when a number of players of the same position are selected in a row, causing owners to think, “Holy crap! All the [QBs, WRs, TEs, etc] are going! I have to get one now!” The result is that they wind up with a not-as-good player, because they jumped on the wave too late.
My advice is to either stay off these or start them. I usually stay off rather than start them, just because it’s easier. But say you’re in the fifth round, and the guy a few picks before you takes Donovan McNabb. Then the next guy takes Matt Hasselbeck. Then the next guy takes Derek Anderson. Then it’s on. You’ll see a flurry of managers selecting QBs that shouldn’t be selected. In this situation, I would back off, take a RB or star WR, and wait a few rounds before taking a serviceable QB (Eli, Cutler, Garrard, etc).
Runs or waves most often happen late in the draft when people pick kickers or defenses. I usually completely ignore these, preferring instead to take a third RB or another QB. Which brings us to…
5) Fuck tight ends, kickers, and defenses. There’s something to be said for having Antonio Gates or Tony Gonzalez, but if you don’t get them in round 4 or 5, forget it. In a 16 round draft, I won’t take these three positions until rounds 12-16. And even then I don’t put much thought into it. I’d rather pick up a different defense every week and draft a backup RB with starting potential than take the Minnesota defense in the 8th. And this year, TE is very, very deep – it’s possible to grab a guy like Todd Heap or Owen Daniels several rounds after Messrs. Whitten, Gates and Gonzalez are gone.
6) Know your enemy. When you’re picking, it’s important to know who the guys around you already have on their teams. For example, say you have the 8th pick in a 10 person league. It’s the 3rd round, and you’re really looking for a QB, but you see that a nice WR has fallen to you. Check to see who the 9th and 10th owners have. If they already have a QB, take the WR with your 3rd round choice and then get the QB on the wrap in the 4th round, following the logic that if the guys picking after you already have a QB, they’re not going to take another one. This knowledge is key.
(This sounds confusing, but it’s not. Basically, if you’re deciding between two positions, look at the people picking after you to see what they need.)
7) Think “best available.” I’m all for filling out your roster positions, but at the same time I adhere to the principle of “best available,” meaning take the best available player, regardless of position. For example, say by the 4th round I’ve drafted two quality RBs and a decent WR. In Round 4, if I see another very good RB who I think has lasted too long, I will take him over a WR that I like, even though I’ve already drafted my two starting RBs and need another WR. Sure, it means that I have one RB too many, but it also means that my competitor won’t have this RB on his team. It’s a wise decision to draft best available because it means a) you’ll have trade bait and b) it’s offensive by being defensive.
This strategy is especially important this year, due to the unprecedented number of RB by committee (RBBC) situations. Previously, it was recommended to go RB-RB in the first two rounds. But this year, by my count about half the teams in the NFL will be spreading their carries out among several RBs. This, combined with the emergence of Tom “God” Brady and the incredible season of Randy Moss and the other talent at the top of the WR pool, means the RB-RB approach may not be the wisest course of action this year.
8 ) Handcuff, handcuff, handcuff. Spend the last few rounds making sure you draft the backups of your marquee players. Players get hurt and their backups step up and often times play well (especially in the case of RBs and, to a lesser extent, QBs). Some must-have handcuffs this year include Jacob Hester (SD), Ray Rice (Bal), Chester Taylor (Min), Ladell Betts (Was) and Lorenzo Booker (Phi), to name a few.
So there are your tips. Now onto the positions.
[Note: We will assume that this is a standard scoring league – four points for QB TD, six for others; no ppr; etc – with ten teams playing head-to-head, the position break-down being: QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, WR, TE, K, DEF. Lists will be broken into tiers, followed by an explanation, followed by players I think are overvalued (i.e. players I think who are going higher in drafts than their performance this year will merit) and players I think are undervalued (um, the opposite over overvalued).]
QUARTERBACK
1 Tom Brady, NE
2 Peyton Manning, Ind
3 Tony Romo, Dal
4 Drew Brees, NO
5 Carson Palmer, Cin
6 Ben Roethlisberger, Pit
7 Matt Hasselbeck, Sea
8 Donovan McNabb, Phi
9 Derek Anderson, Cle
10 Jay Cutler, Den
11 David Garrard, Jax
12 Matt Schaub, Hou
13 Eli Manning, NYG
14 Marc Bulger, StL
15 Philip Rivers, SD
16 Jake Delhomme, Car
17 Brett Favre, NYJ
18 Kurt Warner, Ari
19 Aaron Rodgers, GB
20 Jason Campbell, Was
21 John Kitna, Det
22 Vince Young, Ten
23 Jeff Garcia, TB
24 Trent Edwards, Buf
In a two QB league, Tom Brady is your sixth overall pick, and Peyton, Romo and possibly Brees should all be gone by the start of the third round (as of this writing, I’m not concerned about Manning’s injury and am convinced he’ll play Week One). In a one QB league, you have a lot more freedom and can grab a premier signal-caller later. But be wary – you do not want to end up with Jeff Garcia as your starting QB. According to Yahoo standard scoring, eleven of the top twenty in total points last year were QBs. In order to run with the big dogs in your league, it’s important to get a top-ten QB, so while you can wait a little bit before drafting one, don’t get too cute with the QB position.
Overvalued: As alluded to above, Big Ben is not going to throw 30+ TDs this year (if any of you would like to make a side bet on this, my email again is jason_at_jasonmulgrew.com). Following my “never pay for a career year” advice, I also wouldn’t be thrilled if Derek Anderson was my top QB. I’m not so sure Cleveland is as good as last year’s record indicates and am not a fan of any of the guys in that offense this year. Their inter-conference division is the NFC East and they have games at Jacksonville and against Denver, Houston and Indy. No thanks. I think you have a Jets fan in your league and I think he’s going to take Brett Favre before you do, and I think he’s going to get 24 touchdowns, 23 interceptions and 3800 yards.
Undervalued: “In the past five years, I’ve thrown 26, 22 (in 14 games), 24, 18 (in 12 games) and 28 TDs. I’m bald, kinda dorky, and play in the Northwest, but every year I get drafted way later than I should. My name is Matt Hasselbeck.” Carson Palmer threw a career high 20 INTs last year and could have a nice bounce-back year (he threw 18 INT in his rookie year, but only 12 and 13 in years after that). If you’re a gambler, sixteen games of Donovan McNabb is a top three QB. Marc Bulger shouldn’t be your starter, but you should draft him (he was the #3 QB in 2006 before last year’s injuries and is worth the risk). Schaub is healthy and could be sumpin’ special. If I have to read one more puff piece about Jason Campbell and Jim Zorn, I’m going to consider them legally married.
RUNNING BACK
1 LaDainian Tomlinson, SD*
2 Brian Westbrook, Phi*
3 Adrian Peterson, Min*
4 Joseph Addai, Ind*
5 Stephen Jackson, Stl*
6 Marion Barber, Dal*
7 Clinton Portis, Was*
8 Frank Gore, SF*
9 Marshawn Lynch, Buf*
10 Larry Johnson, KC*
11 Ryan Grant, GB*
12 Maurice Jones-Drew, Jac
13 Willis McGahee, Bal
14 Reggie Bush, NO
15 Willie Parker, Pit
16 Edgerrin James, Ari*
17 Michael Turner, Atl*
18 Thomas Jones, NYJ*
19 Jamal Lewis, Cle*
19.1 Brandon Jacobs, NYG
20 Laurence Maroney, NE
21 Ronnie Brown, Mia
23 Earnest Graham, TB
24 Darren McFadden, Oak
25 Matt Forte, Chi*
26 Lendale White, Ten
27 Fred Taylor, Jax
28 Chris Johnson, Ten
29 DeAngelo Willams, Car
30 Jonathan Stewart, Car
31 Ray Rice, Bal
32 Ricky Williams, Mia
33 Selvin Young, Den
34 Rashard Mendenhall, Pit
35 Kevin Smith, Det
36 Justin Fargas, Oak
37 Felix Jones, Dal
38 Julius Jones, Sea
39 Maurice Morris, Sea
40 Chris Perry, Cin
41 Steve Slaton, Hou
42 Chestor Taylor, Min
43 Jerious Norwood, Atl
44 Rudi Johnson, Cin
45 Ahman Green, Hou
A “*” indicates an RB that will not be splitting carries or involved in a running back by committee situation. The simplest way to view these rankings is that the first tier are the sure things and should be the first five picks in your draft, the second tier is the almost sure things and should be gone by the mid-second at the latest, and the third tier is where it starts getting dangerous – these are high-ceiling RBs, but face committee situations (Bush, MJD, Jacobs, Maroney), injury concerns or old age (Johnson, McGahee, Edge, Lewis, Jones) or are limited experience guys (Grant, Turner).
My strategy is that, depending on the size of the league, I like to walk out of a draft with 4-5 RBs. I’ll try to grab at least one guy from tier one or two above, at least one guy from tier three, one rookie and one handcuff to my top RB. This way you cover all your bases: you’ve got two starters, a back-up/handcuff, and a rookie who just may surprise you.
Overvalued: Call me a homer, but give me the #2 pick and I’m taking Brian Westbrook. I may eat my words, but to me he’s more a sure thing than AP, and a sure thing is what you’re looking for in your first round pick. I’m down on Barber a bit – his physical style and the fact that he’s never had more than 204 carries in a season means that Felix Jones, a favorite of Jerry Jones, could be involved in the running game way more than people think. Here are five guys I would rather not draft:
Larry Johnson – KC stinks and so does their o-line. LJ is coming off major surgery and is older than people realize (29). Could be great, but too much of a question mark.
Ryan Grant – GB caught lightening in a bottle last year with Favre having a career year and their defense playing great, and I don’t think they can repeat their performance. This could come back to haunt me, but I’d rather not be bothered with this guy or his team situation.
Brandon Jacobs – Too much going on it that backfield with Ward and Bradshaw.
Laurence Maroney – One dimensional back in the system that does not favor single, dominant RBs (Corey Dillon’s monster 2004 being the exception). The signing of Lamont Jordan – to go along with Sammy Morris and Kevin Faulk – doesn’t make Maroney any more appealing. He’ll go higher than he should because New England scored 15,000 points last year.
Darren McFadden – Someone’s going to take him way before I’m ready to.
Undervalued: I almost don’t want to say this, since I’ve only had one of my four drafts this year, but where are people shitting on Willie Parker so much? Yeah, he only had 2 TDs last year, and yeah, Mendenhall should see some goal-line carries, but this guy is going way, way later than he should be. I’m not necessarily saying he’ll return to 2006 form (1494 yards, 13 rushing TDs and 3 receiving TDs), but is it much of a stretch to give him 1300 yards and 8-9 TDs? And this guy is being drafted as the RB19?
I also previously liked Thomas Jones, but now that Favre’s on the team, he may be a bit overvalued. Other guys I like and think are being undervalued are Lynch (beast), McGahee (stock has dropped due to injury, but the talent is there – just be sure to grab Rice as your handcuff), and Edge James (expect another quiet 1200-7 season), to name a few. Of the rookies, I’m loving Chris Johnson, mostly because Lendale White likes mayo more than football, and Felix Jones, for reasons stated above.
One last thing: there is real value to be had in a few choice backfields (in order): Cincinnati, Houston and Seattle. Someone’s going to rise up and be a very, very good RB on each of these teams, so watch them closely. If I had to guess, I’d say Perry, Slaton and Jones.
WIDE RECEIVER
1 Randy Moss, NE
2 Terrell Owens, Dal
3 Reggie Wayne, Ind
4 Larry Fitzgerald, Ari
5 Braylon Edwards, Cle
6 Andre Johnson, Hou
7 Marques Colston, NO
8 T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Cin
9 Torry Holt, StL
10 Chad Johnson, Cin
11 Roy Williams, Det
12 Plaxico Burress, NYG
13 Anquan Boldin, Ari
14 Santonio Holmes, Pit
15 Calvin Johnson, Det
16 Anquan Boldin, Ari
17 Steve Smith, Car
18 Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ
19 Wes Welker, NE
20 Roddy White, Atl
21 Donald Driver, GB
22 Brandon Marshall, Den
23 Nate Burleson, Sea
24 Lee Evans, Buf
25 Laverneus Coles, NYJ
26 Dwayne Bowe, KC
27 Marvin Harrison, Ind
28 Hines Ward, Pit
29 Chris Chambers, SD
30 Santana Moss, Was
31 Greg Jennings, GB
32 Ted Ginn, Mia
33 Anthony Gonzalez, Ind
34 Joey Galloway, TB
35 Derrick Mason, Bal
36 Reggie Brown, Phi
37 Bernard Berrian, Min
38 Javon Walker, Oak
39 Mushin Muhammed, Car
40 Patrick Crayton, Dal
Oh, wide receiver – the bane of the fantasy manager’s existence and certainly the hardest position to predict. Once you get back those top 25-30, who will make up the bulk of your league’s WR1 and WR2, you might as well pick out a hat if you’re trying to find the ideal WR3 and WR4 for your team.
The easiest way to circumvent this? If you’re starting three WRs, grab two from the top 25 or so listed above, or even higher. In a one QB league, I’d be inclined to draft some combination of three RBs and three WRs in the first six rounds, eschewing the higher profile TEs (more on this later) and the top half dozen QBs to make sure I’m loaded at those two positions. And this year, considering the decline of the single RB and the rise of the RBBC, I’m personally going to be focusing my efforts more on landing two big-time WRs. For example, I’d feel more comfortable after three rounds with Westbrook, Reggie Wayne and Andre Johnson than with Westbrook, Brandon Jacobs and Earnest Graham, as in the first scenario I’d use many of my later picks to grab high-ceiling rookie RBs or RBCC guys
Overvalued: Steve Smith. And not just because he’s serving a two game suspension. Here’s an email I sent to my roommate Mark, a huge fantasy football guy, just this week:
“You know what? I’ve never been a big Steve Smith fan. If you look at his career stats, he honestly had ONE great year: 2005, when he had 103 catches, 1563 yards and 12 TDs. Otherwise, in the three productive seasons around that (03, 06, 07 - he was hurt in 04), he’s averaged 85 catches, 1100 yards, 7-8 TDs. Numbers for a good WR2, but not for one of the first five WR off the board. He gets by totally on name rep - the Mighty Mite stuff and because he’s brash - and this year, with the two game suspension, there’s no way I’m getting him, since he always goes higher than where I’d take him.
I’m telling you, Steve Smith as WR1 is a myth. Now watch as he goes for 1600 yards and 16 TDs this year.”
I’m down on Braylon Edwards because he’s on the Browns, who I think will be quite bad. Down also on Chad Johnson (injured and typically scores in bunches), Plaxico (SB hangover for the whole team), Roddy White (crappy QB on bad, bad team), Dwayne Bowe (same), Greg Jennings (Favre hangover).
Undervalued: Everyone raving about Calvin Johnson and not talking much about Roy Williams – this could be the year he vaults into the top ten or higher. I love Anquan Boldin, whose upset essentially because his teammate Larry Fitzgerald makes oodles more money than he does. I’ll be targeting Donald Driver, Nate Burleson, Hines Ward, Ted Ginn and Mushin Muhammed in all of my leagues (I bet I’ll end up with at least two of these guys on every team I own).
TIGHT END
1 Jason Whitten, Dal
2 Kellen Winslow, Cle
3 Tony Gonzalez, KC
4 Chris Cooley, Was
5 Dallas Clark, Ind
6 Antonio Gates, SD
7 Jeremy Shockey, NO
8 Tony Scheffler, Den
9 Owen Daniels, Hou
10 Todd Heap, Bal
11 Vernon Davis, SF
12 LJ Smith, Phi
13 Ben Watson, NE
14 Heath Miller, Pit
15 Alge Crumpler, Ten
16 Dustin Keller, NYJ
17 Greg Olsen, Chi
The tier system looks weird with only Shockey by his lonesome in the second one, but hear me out. This year, the cream of the crop is very good. To land one of those top six guys, you’re going to have to use a pick in the first six rounds. Each of them produced between 150 and 126 points, which to put it in perspective, would put them around the same value as WR15 to WR25.
Shortly after the Big Six, Jeremy Shockey should be taken. Count me among the Shockey believers – he couldn’t have landed in a better offensive system and as a complete dickhead, he’d love nothing more to show up the Giants for disrespecting him – but since there are a number of believers, I’m guessing he’s going to be drafted before I’m ready to take him.
That leaves us with that third tier. There are a number of attractive options here that can be drafted rather late, from TEs returning from injury (Todd Heap, LJ Smith) to guys who can really separate themselves this year (Scheffler, Daniels, Davis) to those available at bargain-basement prices who could provide good returns (Crumpler, Watson, Keller).
Because it’s a short list, I won’t do over/undervalued, but here are some thoughts:
- I have Gates so low because I’m concerned about this toe. If I’m going to use a high pick on a TE, a position at which I start only one player per week and usually carry only one, I’m going to use it on the safest bet possible. You can overcome an injury to a RB or WR or QB because you’ll carry so many on your team. If you use a top six pick on a TE and he misses time, you’re in trouble. If you do draft Gates, I strongly suggest grabbing a mid-range backup like Crumpler or LJ Smith.
- I have absolutely no statistical evidence to back this up, but I think Chris Cooley could be gigantic this year.
- I have absolutely no statistical evidence to back this up, but I think Alge Crumpler could be pretty dang good this year. While Vince Young is no Michael Vick, he’s not too far off.
- I say this every year, but maybe this is the one time it comes true: you could do worse than LJ Smith very, very late as your starting TE. He’s a two-time Pro Bowler who got the franchise tag, coming off an injury with something to prove. McNabb has said numerous times in the media this off-season that he wants LJ more involved in the red zone. I’m not saying you should expect 1000 yards and 10 TDs, but you could get something like 600 and 6 or 7, which would put him right around TE7 territory. Not bad for a guy who, according to one site I visit, is on average going in Round 16.
DEFENSE
No rankings here, as I’m one of the most anti-DEF guys I know. I never take a defense before the last few rounds, because, unless you count special teams, too much of it is based on a fluke – a defensive touchdown is worth six points, a huge value, and defensive touchdowns are impossible to predict, even for ball-hawking, high takeaway teams.
For example, here’s the 2007 top five teams in takeaways. The number in parentheses represents how many defensive touchdowns that team scored.
San Diego 48 (5)
Indianapolis 35 (2)
Cincinnati 35 (3)
Tampa Bay 35 (2)
Detroit 35 (4)
And here’s last year’s top five in defensive touchdowns. The number in parentheses represents how many takeaways that team had.
Minnesota 8 (31)
Arizona 6 (29)
New England 6 (31)
San Diego 5 (48)
NYG 5 (25)
NO 5 (23)
What does this tell us? A lot of takeaways does not always equal a lot of defensive touchdowns, and a lot of touchdowns does not always equal a lot of takeaways. San Diego had over twice as many takeaways as New Orleans, but the same amount of defensive touchdowns. Picking a defense is basically a crapshoot, so I’d rather draft one later and use a higher pick not on San Diego, Minnesota or New England, but on a potential break-out WR4 or RB3.
Want more proof? Last year’s number one defense scored 200 points. Last year’s tenth best defense scored 146. That’s a difference of 3.3 points a game. Not entirely inconsequential, but does that 3.3 points per game make it worth drafting a defense in Round 11 as opposed to Round 16? Hardly.
So I recommended two strategies for drafting defenses:
1) The “Who Plays the Shit Team” Strategy. Every week, someone’s going to have to play against Chicago, Miami, Baltimore, Atlanta and Kansas City. Those are five teams that should not put up very strong offensive numbers this year. Every week, simply rotate whatever defense is playing against the guys, preferably one that’s playing at home (i.e. play Carolina when Chicago goes to visit them in Week 2). This will allow you to pick up a defense in the second to last round and use a higher pick on a potential high-ceiling or upside position player.
2) The “Seattle at Home” Strategy. Most fantasy sites have the Seattle defense ranked around the tenth to twelfth best defense, which means you should be able to draft them fairly late. Seattle is a very inhospitable place to play for opposing teams and last year the Seahawks only gave up 13.8 points per game at home. In 2006, the number was inflated because of some shoot-outs (20 points per game), but in 2005, it was down again to 12.8 points per game. Therefore, play Seattle’s defense whenever it’s home and sit them on the road. If you play this properly, you could potentially wind up with a top-five defensive numbers.
(Hell, combine the two strategies – Seattle at home all the time and then whoever’s playing the shit teams above when they’re away.)
KICKER
I’m not going to rank kickers, because under no circumstances should you take one before the very last round of your draft. Some fun with kicker numbers: Last year, according to Yahoo default scoring, the kicker with the most points scored 156. The kicker who was tenth in points scored 132 points. That’s a difference of 1.5 points per game. Can’t say this enough: kickers do not matter. Grab one in the last round.
************
That’s all I got for you. Good luck in your draft and should you win any prize money because of this, please remember who spent a week and about fifteen combined hours putting together the fantasy football preview you used.